The Chance to Compete Act Is the Skills Assessment Mandate No One Funded. Here's How to Meet It Anyway.
With the passage of the Chance to Compete Act, federal agencies were told to stop ranking candidates based on what they say about themselves and start measuring what they can do. The law is clear. The funding and the plan to make it happen are less so. HR teams are left holding a mandate, a deadline, and an assessment build that has historically cost upwards of half a million dollars and taken months to complete. Here’s how your team can meet the mandate on time and within budget, and come out with a hiring process that finds stronger candidates, fills roles faster, and gives every applicant a fair shot at showing what they can do.
In This Article:
What Is the Chance to Compete Act?
The Chance to Compete Act became law in December 2024. It requires federal agencies to assess job candidates with position-specific technical assessments instead of relying mainly on what applicants say about themselves in self-assessment questionnaires.
OPM's implementation plan describes a technical assessment as a position-specific tool, based on job analysis, that lets candidates demonstrate job-related skills. The deadlines to meet the mandate to this point have been malleable. As of September 30, 2025, agencies may use self-assessment questionnaires only to determine minimum qualifications and eligibility. OPM's goal is for every competitive service assessment to be competency-based by fiscal year 2028. The plan also lists milestones already reached, including the Merit Hiring Plan in May 2025, the self-assessment policy change in September 2025, and USA Hire coverage across the full General Schedule in March 2026.
What the Chance to Compete Act Requires From Federal Agencies
Subject matter experts now work alongside HR professionals and industrial-organizational psychologists to analyze each job, design an assessment, and then validate it. OPM expects the result to be job-related, legally defensible, and aligned with the agency's mission.
OPM's plan names several acceptable formats, including situational judgment tests, reasoning assessments, job knowledge tests, work samples and simulations, structured interviews, accomplishment records, and structured reviews of resumes and writing samples.
Agencies have shared options too. OPM's USA Hire Standard measures general competencies such as reasoning, reading, and interpersonal skills for non-supervisory hiring actions, and OPM can build agency-owned assessments on a fee-for-service basis. What agencies can’t do is rate and rank applicants on self-assessment alone without an OPM waiver. The standard is clear, and the work of meeting it lands on agency HR teams.
How the Skills-Based Federal Contracting Act Extends Skills-First Hiring to Contractors
The shift away from credentials is not limited to full-time federal employees. The Skills-Based Federal Contracting Act of 2025 (H.R. 5235) passed the House in February 2026 and the Senate in late September 2026. As of early November 2026, it was awaiting the President's signature.
The bill bars agencies from setting minimum education requirements for proposed contractor personnel in solicitations, unless the contracting officer explains in writing why the agency's needs can’t be met without one.
The bill doesn’t prescribe how to evaluate contractor staff. It pushes the question, what replaces the degree, onto contractors and the agencies that buy from them. Validated skills assessment is a practical answer on both sides of the hiring line.
Why Federal Skills Assessments Are So Expensive to Build
Building one quality assessment has historically cost agencies upwards of half a million dollars and many months of subject matter expert time. The Congressional Budget Office estimated that OPM alone would need $81 million over five years, as the Niskanen Center reports, and OPM's own plan says it and agencies "will require funding and resources" to develop new assessments and run validation studies.
There is a second gap that gets less attention. Shared batteries of assessment tests cover non-supervisory hiring, and OPM points agencies to third-party tools for highly technical roles. Supervisory and specialized positions often need custom work, and those are the roles where how a person approaches the job matters as much as what they know. Judgment, adaptability, and resilience don’t show up on a job knowledge test.
What a Layered Skills Assessment Looks Like for Federal Roles
Most positions need more than one measure, and the right mix depends on the job. These examples are illustrative, not OPM prescriptions.
Benefits claims processor. Accuracy and rule application come first, so a job knowledge test and a work sample built from realistic case files do the heavy lifting. A situational judgment scenario about handling a frustrated claimant adds the interpersonal piece.
IT specialist. Technical depth is the core, so a skills test that mirrors real tasks screens first. A structured interview, scored on the same criteria for every candidate, then tests how the person explains and prioritizes their work.
Supervisory program manager. Job knowledge still matters, but judgment, adaptability, and resilience separate strong supervisors from weak ones. Behavioral assessment and a structured interview carry more weight here than they would for a non-supervisory role.
Layering the measures keeps each one shorter, which respects candidates' time and the 80-day clock set by the OPM Merit Hiring Plan (link to last blog).
How Federal HR Teams Can Build Assessments Without Starting From Scratch
The fastest path is to stop treating every requisition as its own project. Three moves make the work smaller.
Sort roles by what each one needs to measure. Some positions turn on technical skills and job knowledge. Others turn on behavioral skills. Supervisory roles usually need both. Knowing which is which tells you where a shared battery is enough and where you need something new.
Run one rigorous job analysis per job family and reuse it. OPM's guidance calls for job analysis with subject matter expert involvement. Do it once for a family of similar positions, then carry the results across requisitions. Check USA Hire batteries before building anything custom.
Put the budget gap in front of leadership now. Count the roles above GS-04 (since there’s still an exemption in place for grades 01-04) that still depend on self-assessment questionnaires for rating and ranking. A specific number turns a vague funding concern into a request leadership can act on before the FY 2028 target.
Start small. Pick one high-volume job family, pilot the layered approach there, and track how long each stage takes. OPM's plan sets a time-to-hire target of 80 days, down from a baseline of 101, so the pilot doubles as a test of whether better assessment can also move the clock.
How Phenom Helps Agencies Build and Deliver Skills Assessments
Phenom's assessment capabilities now measure both halves of a candidate. Cognitive and situational judgment assessments show how a person reasons through realistic job scenarios. Psychometric and behavioral assessments measure durable skills such as judgment, adaptability, and resilience that a knowledge test cannot capture.
The build-time problem is where this matters most. Phenom's Applied AI agents map behavioral blueprints against more than 40,000 real-world jobs and generate them in hours rather than weeks. That gives agency teams a data-backed starting point for job analysis instead of a blank page. Subject matter experts still review and refine the result, which keeps the process aligned with OPM's requirement for job analysis with SME involvement.
For public sector agency teams, the practical difference is fewer handoffs. Job analysis, assessment design, delivery, and scoring run in one workflow instead of across separate vendors and spreadsheets. Every candidate for a given role is measured against the same criteria, which makes scoring consistent across offices and decisions easier to explain if they are ever questioned.
The agents deliver assessments inline in the hiring flow, so candidates stay in one experience and HR teams get consistent scoring. Structured interviews, one of the formats OPM names, run through the AI Interviewer, which interviews every candidate against a plan reviewed in advance. Phenom for Government is FedRAMP Ready and GovRAMP Ready, in a dedicated environment aligned to FedRAMP Moderate and IL4 controls.
The Bottom Line on Meeting the Chance to Compete Act
The law set the destination, and the budget gap is real. Agencies that wait for appropriations will reach the FY 2028 target with nothing built. Agencies that decide now how to build, reuse, and deliver assessments will fill clinical, benefits-processing, and safety-critical roles with better-matched people sooner. The mandate is unfunded. The work does not have to start from zero.
Get the latest applied AI insights delivered to your inbox.
Sign up to stay up-to-date on the latest original content from Phenom, including new podcast episodes, events, and more.










